Illinois Supreme Court: Smell of Burnt Cannabis Insufficient Cause for Police Vehicle Search

The Illinois Supreme Court recently made a significant ruling that could change how police conduct vehicle searches in the state, especially when it comes to marijuana. In a unanimous decision, the court ruled that the smell of burnt cannabis by itself is not enough for police to search a vehicle without a warrant. This decision marks a shift in how cannabis is treated in Illinois since the state legalized its recreational use in 2020.

The case that led to this ruling involved a man named Ryan Redmond, who was stopped by a state trooper for minor traffic violations in 2020 (going 73 in 70 on interstate 80). He was traveling from Des Moines back to Chicago. The officer said he smelled burnt cannabis coming from the car and, based on that alone, searched the vehicle, finding a small amount of cannabis enclosed in a plastic bag in the center console. Even though it’s illegal to smoke marijuana while driving, there was no indication that Redmond had and the court decided that just the smell of cannabis, without other evidence of wrongdoing, wasn’t enough to justify searching Redmond’s car in the first place.

Before marijuana was legalized in Illinois, the smell of cannabis was often all police needed to search a car; call it probable cause. But now, the court has said that this approach no longer works in the same way. The reasoning is simple: cannabis is legal for adults, just like alcohol in Illinois. You can possess it, but there are rules about where and how it can be used, such as not smoking it while driving. Therefore, the smell of marijuana, much like alcohol, doesn’t automatically mean someone is breaking the law.

Get our free mobile app

This decision is important for Illinois residents because it protects their Fourth Amendment rights, which safeguards against unreasonable searches. While police can still consider the smell of marijuana as one part of an overall assessment, they will need more concrete evidence to conduct a search without a warrant, during a traffic stop.

On the other hand, police officers and organizations have raised concerns that this ruling could make it harder for them to do their jobs. They worry about scenarios where drugs other than cannabis are involved or where minors could be found with cannabis. For law enforcement, figuring out how to handle these situations under the new guidelines might pose a challenge and lead to many cases being thrown out in court. This ruling could have far-reaching consequences for those already in the court system under similar circumstances.

For Illinois residents, this ruling means more protection from unwarranted vehicle searches, but it’s also a reminder that driving while impaired or smoking marijuana in a vehicle is still illegal, with loads of gray area yet to be explored. Police will have to adapt to these new standards, but the court’s decision underscores the idea that cannabis, now legal in the state, should be treated more like alcohol in the eyes of Illinois law enforcement.