Toxic Apple Juice Sparks Mass Recall in Iowa, Illinois, and Wisconsin

If you recently picked up a bottle or pack of Martinelli’s apple juice, you'll want to check your pantry.

S. Martinelli & Company has voluntarily recalled over 170,000 bottles of its 10-ounce apple juice after concerns about patulin contamination. Patulin is a toxic substance, known as a mycotoxin, produced by certain molds. It's often found in rotting apples. The recall, announced on March 18th, 2025, affects bottles sold in Iowa, Illinois, Wisconsin, and 25 other states.

Get our free mobile app

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) classified the recall as Class II on April 22nd. Class 2 means the product could cause temporary or medically reversible health issues. Patulin exposure can lead to symptoms like nausea, vomiting, and gastrointestinal distress, according to the FDA. Additionally, pasteurization does not remove patulin once it is present. The FDA also regulates and sets a standard for what is an acceptable level of patulin.

The affected juice was sold in clear, round 10-ounce glass bottles with a white metal screw top. Consumers are advised to look for bottles with a "Best By" date of December 5, 2026 and UPC code 0 41244 04102 2. Retailers such as Fareway, Hy-Vee, Target, Walmart, and Whole Foods stocked the recalled juice across the Midwest. In total, 7,234 cases are being pulled from shelves. That's essentially 173,616 bottles: a huge loss, considering Martinelli’s reputation for premium apple juice.

If you find a bottle matching the recall details, the FDA advises you not to drink it. Instead, return it to the store or contact Martinelli’s directly for instructions. If you’ve already consumed the juice and experience any symptoms, consult a medical professional.

A few seconds checking your bottle could help you avoid a very unpleasant reaction, and a trip to the doctor. For now, look closely before taking that next sip.