Walmart Finally Pulls Back on Self-Checkouts in Illinois, Iowa, and Wisconsin

When self-checkouts were first introduced, I was kind of for them. I could get in and get out, no worries. However, my sentiment changed once I had a family and a massive grocery cart full to the brim, which I then had to scan and bag, after already shopping for over an hour. It takes away any "fun" that shopping was and makes it even more of a chore. Well, it looks like Walmart wised up and is walking back one of its most controversial experiments. Get ready for a new shopping experience across Iowa, Illinois, and Wisconsin, as the results are in on self-checkouts.

Self-checkouts, once billed as the future of retail, are being removed from dozens of Walmart locations in the Midwest. After years of customer complaints, confusing technology, and soaring theft, the retail giant is making a quiet retreat. And they may not be the only ones.

Get our free mobile app

Why the Change?

The issues go way beyond annoyance. Self-checkout didn’t just frustrate customers (myself included), it failed the company and the consumers on multiple levels.

• Increased Theft: Stores reported rampant shoplifting. A Walmart in Missouri saw police calls drop over 60% after removing kiosks. That kind of stat forced corporate heads to reconsider the math.
• Security Breaches: Skimmers were found at self-checkout terminals in multiple states, including Illinois, compromising card data and shattering customer trust.
• Customer Fatigue: For years, Midwest shoppers have voiced the same concern: “Why am I doing all the work?” Bagging your groceries, dealing with errors, and hunting for an employee when things go wrong. As if the bill wasn't enough, self-checkouts turned grocery runs into forced labor.

Here's the thing, I honestly despise shopping at Walmart because I'm tired of scanning $200 worth of groceries and bagging them while just one person watches eight lanes. It’s not faster, and it shows consumers what you really think of them. That they are a bank to withdraw from. No more customer service; instead, the customer became both the server and the served. Pretty messed up.

Walmart’s Midwest Reversal

Walmart locations in Cedar Rapids, Des Moines, Rockford, Springfield, Madison, and beyond are starting to remove or reduce self-checkout lanes. With the current update finishing on July 27th at the Dubuque Walmart, it will be interesting to see what changes are made here. The company hasn’t released a full list, but employees in multiple stores confirmed that kiosks are being taken out or limited to fewer lanes.

Listen, I think it's a great option, but it should definitely not be the ONLY option for checkout. Shopping used to be something that people enjoyed (at least a little bit anyway), but making the consumer "work" on top of already paying for the goods is a bit greedy. It also doesn't put any economy back into the local workforce, as fewer cashiers are needed.

A Retail Wake-Up Call? Maybe...

This isn’t just about one company. Walmart’s pullback signals a broader truth: Automation only works when it works for people. And in many communities, especially in the Tri-States, it didn’t.

• People value service.
• They want real help when things go wrong.
• And they’re not looking to be turned into part-time, unpaid employees.

Walmart isn’t going fully back to the 1990s. Instead, insiders suggest a “hybrid model” is coming. This means some automation, yes, but with more human staff, more attention, and hopefully an easier process. This shift may also inspire other chains to reconsider their own checkout strategies. After all, Walmart doesn’t make a move this big unless the data is loud and clear.

Well, I guess congratulations are in order for those stubborn and passively aggressive Midwest shoppers. We have long felt ignored in the self-checkout debate. Now, with hard numbers backing up our frustration, it seems the tide is finally turning. What began as a high-tech gamble to pocket more profit has ended in a return to basics: real people, real service, and maybe a real reason to come back.